Brooklyn Bookseller Fills Neighborhood Void
Emma Straub and Michael Fusco Straub opened their independent bookstore in 2017 to replace a closing competitor, now serving two locations with a focus on local authors and children's literacy.
By Julia Wang ·

Emma Straub and Michael Fusco Straub opened Books Are Magic in 2017 to address the closure of BookCourt in Cobble Hill. The novelists sought to preserve a neighborhood gathering place while establishing a venue for authors to connect with readers. Nicole Vasquez, the store’s marketing coordinator, noted that Straub viewed the shop as essential to her community. She stated that losing the neighborhood bookstore was a concern she could not ignore.
The business has since expanded to a second location on Montague Street in Brooklyn Heights. The stores host regular programming, including author events and free children’s storytimes. These sessions occur on Tuesdays at the Smith Street location and Thursdays at the Montague Street location. Staff members said these events allow residents to meet writers in smaller settings. The bookstore has hosted appearances by Virginia Evans, Ethan Hawke, Margaret Atwood, and Matt Dinnaman.
A central feature of the store is its children’s section, which staff described as carefully curated. Yeshim Kayim-Yanko, the marketing and events coordinator, said the selection is incredible. The team emphasized the need to make children’s literature accessible, citing data from ProLiteracy. That organization found that one in six high school students drops out each year, with illiteracy as a major factor. ProLiteracy also hypothesized that students who fall behind at kindergarten make up the largest portion of dropouts.
For adult readers, the store relies on personal recommendations rather than bestseller lists. Employees write individual notes, known as shelf talkers, to introduce books they have read. Kayim-Yanko said this approach differs from corporate chains. She noted that customers often ask for specific staff members' recommendations. One employee, Bex, has developed a following among shoppers who seek out their particular taste in literature.
Staff members use social media to attract new readers, describing viral titles as a foot in the door. They hope customers arrive for popular books and leave with unexpected finds. The coordinators observed renewed interest in independent bookstores across other cities. They also noted the growing popularity of venues that combine bookselling with cafes or bars. For Brooklyn, they said the bookstore culture remains distinct.
Small Business Saturday offers an opportunity to introduce the store to locals who may not know it exists. Vasquez said many visitors are surprised to learn the shop is in their neighborhood. She added that people frequently ask when the store opened. The coordinators view this holiday as a chance to remind shoppers to support independent businesses alongside major retailers. They also pointed to Independent Bookstore Day on April 27 as another annual event for local shops.
More Business · Business Watchdog · Report a business · Got a Story?






