Judge keeps $15 billion Trump lawsuit against New York Times alive
Federal Judge Steven Merryday ruled that specific claims about tax crimes can proceed, while dismissing two other counts in the high-stakes defamation case.
By Julia Wang ·

Federal Judge Steven Merryday in Florida ruled on Thursday that a major portion of President Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House will move forward. The court determined that the complaint sufficiently alleges that certain descriptions of the president’s tax planning were based on incomplete data. This decision allows the case to enter the next phase of legal proceedings despite earlier attempts to throw it out.
Trump filed the suit in September 2025. The complaint targets two articles and a book that scrutinized his business record. The specific book at issue is titled “Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success.” It was written by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig. The lawsuit also cites articles by those two journalists and by Peter Baker. Trump is seeking at least $15 billion in damages for what he argues are defamatory statements.
In his written decision, Merryday found that the plaintiffs plausibly claimed that describing Trump’s tax offenses as “complex” relied on information that was not fully vetted. The judge stated that the authors and editors did not obtain sufficient expert assessment to back those specific characterizations. This finding provides a legal basis for the remaining claims to be tested in court.
The ruling was not a complete victory for the president. Merryday dismissed two of the claims in the original filing. The judge also ruled that 27 other specific statements could not proceed under the standard of actual malice. Those 27 assertions remain part of the case background but are not currently active counts for defamation.
This outcome follows a similar ruling earlier this week. A different federal judge allowed Trump’s separate lawsuit against the BBC to continue. That case involves the network’s alleged deceptive editing of a video. The recent decision in Florida marks another judicial win for the administration’s media litigation strategy.
The current case is distinct from a previous suit Trump filed against the same newspaper. In that earlier dispute, which centered on the paper’s 2018 investigation into family taxes, a judge dismissed the claims against the publication and three reporters. In January 2024, a court ordered Trump to pay $392,638 in legal fees to the defendants in that matter.
The defendants now have 28 days to file a formal response to the charges that remain active. The next step in the litigation will depend on that filing and subsequent scheduling orders from the court.






