NYC Council moves to ban Amazon delivery contractors
The Delivery Protection Act would require the e-commerce giant to hire its third-party delivery drivers directly, a move backed by the Teamsters and opposed by small business owners.
By Julia Wang ·

The New York City Council is advancing legislation that would force Amazon to directly employ the drivers who deliver its packages, ending the use of third-party contractors for in-city deliveries. The Delivery Protection Act currently holds 35 co-sponsors, a number well past the majority required for passage. If the bill clears the council, Mayor Zohran Mamdani has indicated he will sign it into law.
The measure targets the current structure where workers deliver Amazon-branded packages while employed by independent delivery service providers, or DSPs. More than 40 such companies operate in the city. Proponents argue this arrangement shields Amazon from liability and weakens union power. The International Brotherhood of Teamsters, which has approximately 1.3 million active members, supports the bill.
Amazon opposes the legislation, arguing it will destroy a network of small businesses. The company has spent millions lobbying against the proposal. According to city data, a group called the Five Borough Jobs Campaign has spent over $8 million on lobbying efforts this year. Amazon spokesperson Kelly Nantel stated that the legislation threatens the jobs of more than 5,000 employees at these small business partners.
Julissa Alvarez, who owns Brimela Routes Corp, said the bill would force her employees to go through a new hiring pipeline rather than being retained by Amazon. She expressed concern that the company is not being forced to hire her staff directly. "There's people today that I employ that will be overlooked if this bill passes through," Alvarez said.
Gabrielly Sierra-Moreno, a 21-year-old driver for Brimela Routes, works near StuyTown in Manhattan. She said she prefers working for a small employer because she knows her boss personally and they communicate in Spanish. She cited flexible scheduling and easy access to paid time off as benefits of the current system. "I wouldn't want them to get shut down," Sierra-Moreno said.
Drivers for other DSPs, however, cite safety concerns. LeAnn Rivera, a driver for Excell Logistics at the DBK1 warehouse in Woodside, Queens, said her van often had mechanical issues. She described a recent incident where the van kept rolling after she engaged the emergency brake. Samuel Mangual, another driver at the same location, reported faulty brakes and a van door that would not close, forcing him to stop deliveries for fear of theft.
José Huerta, a driver for Fast Track Delivery Inc. and a Teamsters organizer, said the contractor model allows Amazon and the DSPs to shift responsibility for accidents. "Right now, if any accident happens to one of us drivers, Amazon claims the DSP is responsible," Huerta said. "The DSP, on the other hand, says no, that it’s Amazon that’s responsible. In other words, they just blame each other."
Excell Logistics did not respond to requests for comment. Amar Patel, president of Fast Track Delivery, denied that the vans were unsafe, stating that vehicles with safety defects are grounded until repairs are complete. Drivers at Amazon's Queens warehouse organized with Teamsters Local 804 in December to demand better safety standards and higher pay. They currently work 10-hour shifts delivering up to 230 packages a day for an average wage of $24 an hour.
Council Speaker Julie Menin said her office is working on changes to address legal concerns. "To be clear, we are going to be regulating Amazon," Menin said. "We will be the first city in the country to regulate Amazon in a very significant way." Marc Morial, president of the National Urban League, called the third-party companies a "political football," noting that many owners took out loans to build their businesses. Amazon is a diamond partner of the league, having contributed more than $1 million.
Orin Starn, an anthropology professor at Duke University, said the bill could serve as a model for other cities if it passes. Alvarez, the Brimela Routes owner, said she supports reforms that mandate better oversight but do not eliminate the contractor system. "What about me? I am also one of your constituents," Alvarez said. "Are you trying to kill my business, my family, my dreams, my opportunity to help the community?"
More Business · Business Watchdog · Report a business · Got a Story?






