Port Jefferson storefronts change hands as Main Street traffic drives new ventures
Chamber of Commerce officials say new expansions and a historic building move are offsetting several long-time departures in the village center.
By Julia Wang ·

The Port Jefferson downtown business district is undergoing a rapid turnover that has already resulted in several familiar storefronts changing hands this year. Barbara Ransome, Director of Operations at the Greater Port Jefferson Chamber of Commerce, stated that the recent activity is not an indicator of economic decline but rather a natural cycle of growth and replacement.
The timeline of changes began with the departure of Kate and Hale from its Main Street location. That space is now scheduled to welcome House Boutique, which is currently operating on East Main Street. Lee Pennisi, who owns the boutique, plans to begin her relocation on Dec. 1. The new location is a historic building that previously functioned as a bank and a jail. Pennisi noted that the move provides greater visibility and access to the higher volume of foot traffic on Main Street compared to her current East Main Street location.
Following the departure of Kilwins, the long-time ice cream and confectionery shop, the neighboring Celtic Apothecary is also not renewing its lease. The Pie, located next door, intends to expand into the vacant space. This expansion involves breaking through the adjoining wall to create a bar and a dedicated event room for private gatherings and children's parties. Ransome observed that the restaurant previously lacked these specific amenities, making the new space a logical addition to its operations.
Other businesses are also preparing for transitions. The Fifth Season is expected to leave in January, according to information Ransome has received but has not yet fully confirmed. Unique Boutique in Chandler Square is closing its doors. In contrast, new establishments are opening to fill the gaps. The Canopy Club has opened in Chandler Square, offering breakfast and lunch in the former location of Gourmet Burger Bistro. My Town's Cafe is set to open toward the end of November in a former East Main Street boutique space. The cafe will serve coffee, pastries, and quiches and will operate as a wine bar.
The Port Jefferson Motorcycle Store is seeking a new owner as its longtime proprietor prepares to retire. Bounce Salon on East Main Street is consolidating its operations by closing its upstairs space while maintaining its downstairs salon. Ransome also pointed to the growing popularity of Baker's Alley, where artisan baker Gregory Wilson operates Rustic Bread. The bakery, open Friday through Sunday, sells out of breads and croissants on weekends. The location's name derives from historical baking ovens that once operated in the basement with ventilation running beneath East Main Street.
Ransome cautioned against attributing the recent departures solely to parking challenges in the village. She described parking as one component of a business's overall health rather than the sole deciding factor. She cited a conversation with Jiten Singh, owner of Local's Cafe, who reported that the business had its best year ever. Ransome used this example to counter the perception that the downtown area is struggling.
House Boutique is scheduled to hold its grand opening on Jan. 17, aiming to be open in time for the holiday season. The Chamber of Commerce continues to monitor the activity in the district, noting that the influx of new businesses is helping to keep storefronts occupied. The transition of the historic building into a retail space for House Boutique represents a specific effort to utilize prominent Main Street real estate for new commercial activity.
More Business · Business Watchdog · Report a business · Got a Story?






