Student Visas: Federal Judge Strikes Down Four-Year Cap
A Boston judge ruled that the new DHS limit is arbitrary, restoring the ability for international students to stay in the U.S. for the full duration of their academic programs.
By Adrian Kovalenko ·

A federal judge in Boston struck down the Trump administration’s new rule limiting international student visas to four years on Monday. The decision removes the cap, allowing F-1 and J-1 visa holders to remain in the United States for as long as they are enrolled in their academic programs.
District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV declared the Department of Homeland Security rule to be arbitrary and a capricious abuse of discretion. He stated that the agency was trying to discourage the very educational opportunities that Congress intended to foster. Saylor noted that a four-year limit had no rational connection to national security, a point he raised during an August hearing.
The rule was scheduled to take effect on September 15 but was blocked temporarily by Saylor on September 14. The Monday ruling makes that blockage permanent. The government has appealed the initial temporary order, and that appeal remains pending. Neither the Department of Justice nor the DHS responded to requests for comment.
The policy would have restricted university transfers and banned double degrees at the same level, such as combined medical and doctoral programs. University leaders warned that the cap would disproportionately harm graduate students. Colin Duckett, the president of Boston University, noted that a doctoral degree takes an average of 5.7 years to complete.
The lawsuit was filed in August by a coalition of non-profit groups and unions, including the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration. The Alliance argued that the rule caused immediate financial harm rather than a future threat. Miriam Feldblum, the Alliance president, said the damage was already visible.
Massachusetts hosts a high number of international students. This year, 41% of MIT graduate students are from abroad. Northeastern University enrolled nearly 21,000 international students last year, while Boston University had just over 11,000. A drop in enrollment this fall could cost the state approximately $200 million.
National enrollment data shows a 9% decline in international students this fall, following a 3% drop the previous year. The ruling restores the traditional duration of status policy that has been in place for decades.






