AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsThe latest from the cities that shape the country.
Wire Authority · 3970 Post Road, Warwick, RI 02886
News · Brooklyn

UFT Files Notice of Claim Against Teachers Retirement System Over Pension Errors

The union seeks legal recourse for 183 disabled retirees whose pensions were reduced to recover overpayments traced to administrative mistakes.

By Adrian Kovalenko ·

Illustration for: UFT Files Notice of Claim Against Teachers Retirement System Over Pension Errors
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The United Federation of Teachers has initiated legal proceedings against the city’s Teachers Retirement System regarding the adjustment of pension benefits for retired paraprofessionals.

The union filed a notice of claim with the city comptroller’s office on Tuesday. This procedural step is required before the group can sue the city for damages. UFT president Michael Mulgrew disclosed the filing during a delegates assembly on Wednesday evening. He stated that the union attempted to reach a resolution but believed a timely administrative fix was no longer possible.

Mulgrew argued that the retirement system should not punish retirees for errors made by the fund’s administrators. "But we’re not going to sit here and just say because TRS and others made a mistake over 20 years ago that these paraprofessionals are going to have their lives completely upset," Mulgrew said. The union’s filing suggests it will argue that the pension system has the discretion to protect those least able to afford financial harm caused by its own mistakes.

The dispute centers on a group of 183 disabled retired paraprofessionals who learned in mid-June that their monthly payments would be cut. The Teachers Retirement System determined that these individuals had been overpaid for more than two decades. By some estimates, the overpayments cost the fund approximately $155,000 per month. The system will now recoup the excess amounts from future checks, reducing some monthly benefits by as much as half.

The error stemmed from a misclassification of the retirees’ disability status. State law entitles Workers’ Compensation-eligible retirees to pensions equal to one-third of their final average salaries. The retirement system had erroneously calculated the benefits at two-thirds. The affected workers retired early due to job-related injuries, including assaults by students that required surgery and physical therapy.

City officials maintain that the city is legally obligated to correct the payments. Mayor Zohran Mamdani stated in August that the Law Department identified the issue as a long-standing mistake requiring legal compliance. Law Department spokesperson Nicholas Paolucci confirmed the notice of claim is under review. A City Hall spokesperson said the administration had no further comment. The Teachers Retirement System board of trustees is scheduled to meet on Thursday afternoon.

The financial impact on the retirees has been severe. Current top salaries for paraprofessionals are $56,700 per year, but the affected individuals retired more than 10 years ago when wages were lower. Anthony Delgardio, who retired from a Brooklyn special education high school over 12 years ago after being attacked by a student, now receives less than $1,000 per month. The system also informed him it would collect over $38,000 in overpayments from his future checks.

Delgardio, who now lives with his sister in Long Island to reduce expenses, said he assumed the initial notification letter was a scam. He is considering selling his home and reported that he currently cannot afford basic necessities. Several other affected retirees told reporters in August that they had stopped seeing doctors or filling prescriptions due to the reduced income.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Wire Authority in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. Top Online Sportsbooks Offer Nearly $4,000 in NBA Betting Promos for Nov. 20
  2. Three Arab men shot dead in Israel within a single day
  3. Tashima Remains in FIFA Presidential Race Against Infantino
  4. German Youth Rally to Resist Military Expansion and Rising Defense Costs
  5. A24 box office surge strengthens HBO Max streaming position
Get Wire Authority in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.