AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsThe latest from the cities that shape the country.
Wire Authority · 3970 Post Road, Warwick, RI 02886

Judge Permits Trump's $15 Billion Lawsuit Against New York Times to Advance

A federal judge has ruled that President Trump's defamation suit against the New York Times and Penguin Random House can move forward after denying a motion to dismiss.

By News Media House Staff ·

Illustration for: Judge Permits Trump's $15 Billion Lawsuit Against New York Times to Advance
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

President Donald Trump is permitted to proceed with a $15 billion lawsuit against the New York Times, its reporters, and publisher Penguin Random House. Judge Steven Merryday issued a ruling that denied the defendants' motion to dismiss, determining that the plaintiff has stated a plausible claim that the media outlets acted recklessly in alleging tax fraud.

The legal dispute centers on the book Lucky Loser, which contains various assertions regarding Trump's business history. The judge found that several claims within the text are potentially defamatory because they present the president's financial conduct as fraudulent without definitive proof. Specifically, the book cites tax experts who described Trump's actions as highly suspicious and noted that the situation smells like a crime. However, the court determined that these descriptions were not sufficient to state outright that Trump had committed tax evasion or fraud.

Merryday explained that a clear-cut judgment of fraud would require an explicit opinion from a qualified source after a thorough examination of the pertinent facts. Since the book did not include such a definitive statement, the reporters were operating in risky legal territory. The judge wrote that the authors knew they did not have absolute certainty but proceeded undeterred with their reporting.

A central allegation in the book is that Trump obtained the equivalent of $400 million from his father, Fred, largely through fraudulent tax evasion schemes. The text also asserted that Fred Trump engaged in likely tax fraud by giving his son gifts that were disguised as loans. The book claimed this arrangement was specifically designed to avoid gift and estate taxes. In his filing, Trump argued that these statements were false because neither he nor his father had ever been formally charged with a tax crime.

The New York Times published two separate articles drawn from the book in 2024. In his decision, Judge Merryday dismissed the claims pertaining to the first article, which focused on Trump's relationship with TV producer Mark Burnett and the development of the show The Apprentice. The judge also tossed out statements from the second article that focused on Trump's school record.

However, the lawsuit will continue regarding one specific statement from that second article. The judge allowed Trump to sue over the claim that authorities had investigated his ties to the Mafia and had found violations of money laundering laws. This portion of the reporting remains at the heart of the ongoing legal battle between the president and the news organization.

This is not the first time the case has faced procedural hurdles. The same judge dismissed an earlier version of Trump's lawsuit last year, criticizing it for being overlong and full of colorful but irrelevant detail. Following that dismissal, Trump's legal team refiled a more concise version of the complaint a month later, which is the version now being reviewed.

With the motion to dismiss denied, the suit can now proceed to the discovery phase and subsequent motions for summary judgment. The defendants in the case include the New York Times, three of its reporters, and Penguin Random House. The outcome of this high-stakes litigation may have significant implications for media liability and defamation standards in the coming years.

Originally published by News Media House

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Wire Authority in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. Top Online Sportsbooks Offer Nearly $4,000 in NBA Betting Promos for Nov. 20
  2. Three Arab men shot dead in Israel within a single day
  3. Tashima Remains in FIFA Presidential Race Against Infantino
  4. German Youth Rally to Resist Military Expansion and Rising Defense Costs
  5. A24 box office surge strengthens HBO Max streaming position
Get Wire Authority in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.